How Do You Choose an AI SEO Agency?

Choose an AI SEO agency by checking four things: a published price, a stated contract term, a named way of counting AI citations, and no promise of a ranking. Of 18 agencies we checked in October 2026, only 5 show an explicitly labeled AI SEO, AEO or GEO price. WebFX publishes an entry price of $3,000 a month, and Hook publishes $3,750 for Local SEO + AEO.
By Ryan Goering, founder of BaaDigi. Last updated: November 2026.
Ryan's take: The biggest thing when choosing an agency is results. A lot of people don't even check if that agency is ranking on AI for any searches. I've found that people sign up with anyone who has a good salesman, and they don't check whether that company knows anything about SEO or AI SEO.
Can an AI agent actually use your website?
AI agents are starting to visit sites on a customer's behalf — comparing companies and requesting quotes. We run the same agentic browsing checks Google built into Chrome and show you what an agent hits when it lands on your site. No email to run it.
What should you check before hiring an AI SEO agency?
Four checks cover most of the risk, and you can run all of them before a sales call.
- Is the price on the website? A price is the easiest fact to publish and the hardest to dodge. If it is missing, ask for the monthly figure in writing before you book a demo, and note whether it covers content, tracking or both.
- What is the minimum term? Published minimum terms include four months at Digital Elevator and six months at WebFX; First Page Sage lists month-to-month terms. Know it before you sign, and get it in writing, because a long minimum term is a very different commitment from a month-to-month plan.
- How do they count AI citations? Ask which engines, how many prompts, how often, and who wrote the prompts. "We track your visibility" is not an answer.
- Do they promise a result? Nobody controls whether ChatGPT names you. OpenAI says so on its own help page: “Placement is not guaranteed.”
What do AI SEO agencies publish for price and terms?
We opened the pricing or service page of 18 agencies at the end of October 2026 and recorded what each one prints. We found an explicitly labeled AI SEO, AEO or GEO price on the pages checked for five of eighteen agencies. Searchbloom published an SEO starting price without a separate GEO price. We found no labeled price for the other thirteen, including Thrive, Single Grain, iPullRank, NP Digital and Scorpion; that describes the pages we checked, not every route to a quote. Here are the five, plus us.
| Agency | Published AI SEO price | Published term |
|---|---|---|
| WebFX | $3,000/mo (Bronze) up to $68,250/mo (Enterprise+) | 6-month commitment |
| Hook Agency | $3,750/mo, Local SEO + AEO | Not stated |
| Digital Elevator | $1,000/mo AI add-on on top of $1,500/mo local SEO | 4-month minimum, then 30 days notice |
| First Page Sage | $6,000–$12,000/mo | Month to month |
| Omniscient Digital | From $120,000/year | Minimum term not verified |
| BaaDigi | $297, $497, $1,397 or $3,997/mo; $700 setup on Foundation, $995 on Stability | Month to month |
First Page Sage also publishes a market survey on the same page. It puts the “Starter” tier for local and small businesses at $1,800–$4,200 a month, with a median of $2,950 and a three-month minimum. Hook currently lists Local SEO + AEO at $3,750 a month. BaaDigi’s bundled growth engines cost $297–$3,997 a month; Foundation has $700 setup and Stability has $995 setup. Compare the included AI-search work before treating these as equivalent packages. Check the live page, not a roundup, including ours. The full list is on our generative engine optimization agencies comparison.
Does the research justify what AI SEO agencies promise?
Partly, and the limits matter when you read a pitch. The paper that coined “generative engine optimization” (Princeton and partners, KDD 2024) reported that adding citations, quotations and statistics lifted visibility by up to 40% on its own metric. The same paper says the benchmark holds 10,000 queries, the reported gains come from its 1,000-query test split, and the engine was one the authors built, that the check on real Perplexity used a 200-example subset and showed up to 37%, and that results “vary across domains.” It is a good argument for putting sources and numbers in your content. It is not a forecast for your business.
Google is blunter. Its documentation says there are “no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary.” An Ahrefs study of 1,885 pages that added schema, against 4,000 control pages, found no major citation uplift. So be wary of any agency that sells a secret file, a special markup or a proprietary trick. Good AI SEO is good SEO plus content that answers a question in a quotable passage, with real numbers on the page.
How fast should an AI SEO agency say results will arrive?
No platform publishes this, so treat every timeline as an estimate. Two vendor studies from 2026 give a range. maxaeo tracked 740 new pages and reported a median of 13 days to a first citation and 41 days to a stable one. Profound reported a median of 6.81 days to a first ChatGPT or Claude citation. Both count only pages that eventually got cited, and both come from companies that sell AI visibility tools. A fair reading: new pages can be cited within weeks, and anyone promising a date is guessing. Ask an agency what it will report in months one, two and three, not what it will deliver.
How should an agency measure AI citations?
With a fixed prompt list, several engines, a schedule and the raw URLs. Here is ours, so you can compare. BaaDigi's tracker re-asks 310 prompts we wrote to ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews every few days and stores every cited URL. In October 2026 (the tracker runs through October 26) it logged baadigi.com in 24.7% of ChatGPT runs, 33.6% of Perplexity runs and 7.1% of Google AI Overview runs. Three engines, three very different answers. A report that gives one blended "AI visibility score" hides that.
Read that number with care. We wrote the prompts, many of them aim at pages we built, and a rate is a share of engine runs, not of buyers. The same discipline applies to us in the other direction: in our own roundup of GEO agencies, 29 AI answers named WebFX 14 times and BaaDigi 0 times. If an agency shows you a chart that only goes up, ask for the prompt list.
I have built search visibility for local service companies since 2008. The agencies that last are the ones whose reports you can check yourself.
Which AI SEO agency should you choose?
- If you want a fixed price and a short commitment: Compare the published minimum terms separately from price. First Page Sage lists month-to-month terms; Hook’s pricing page does not state its retainer term.
- If the pitch includes a guarantee of rankings or citations: do not buy it. Nobody controls an engine’s choice, and OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed.
- If you only want to know where you stand first: run a free check before paying anyone. Our AI search visibility checker shows whether ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google name your business today.
- If you are a local service business: see our guide to choosing a contractor SEO agency, which applies the same checks to local search.
Who does AI recommend, and which sources does it cite?
More people ask ChatGPT and AI search “who's the best contractor near me?” every day. See if AI names you — or sends the job to someone else. No email to run it.
Free website audit — see what's costing you leads
No email required. Takes 2 minutes. Completely free.

Ryan Goering
CEO & Founder, BaaDigi
U.S. military veteran and digital marketing strategist who built BaaDigi to help contractors generate predictable leads and revenue. 15+ years in SEO, PPC, and AI-powered marketing automation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does an AI SEO agency cost?▼
From a $1,000 monthly add-on to $68,250 a month. WebFX publishes an entry price of $3,000 a month, and Hook publishes $3,750 for Local SEO + AEO. BaaDigi's bundled growth engines cost $297–$3,997 a month; Foundation has $700 setup and Stability has $995 setup. Compare the included AI-search work before treating these as equivalent packages.
Is AI SEO different from regular SEO?▼
Mostly an extension of it. Google says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and Ahrefs treats GEO, AEO and LLMO as three names for one idea. What changes is measurement and format: you track citations in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, and write passages an engine can quote with a real number in them.
Can an AI SEO agency guarantee I will appear in ChatGPT?▼
No. OpenAI states that placement is not guaranteed, and a guarantee of citations or rankings is a reason to walk away.
How long does AI SEO take to work?▼
No platform publishes this. Two 2026 vendor studies found a median of 13 days (maxaeo) and 6.81 days (Profound) to a first citation for new pages, and maxaeo found 41 days to a stable one. Both counted only pages that were eventually cited, so use them as a rough range, not a promise. Ask the agency what it will report in months one, two and three instead.
What should an AI SEO report show?▼
Which engines were checked, how many prompts, who wrote them, how often they ran, and the cited URLs behind every number. Citation rates differ sharply by engine. In October 2026 (the tracker runs through October 26) our own tracker showed 24.7% on ChatGPT, 33.6% on Perplexity and 7.1% on Google AI Overviews, so a single blended score hides what is happening. Also ask for the cited URLs, not just percentages, so you can open the pages the engines read and see for yourself whether your business was named, which competitors appeared beside it, and whether the answer links to you at all.
Popular Contractor Marketing Guides
HVAC SEO by City
We serve contractors nationwide — based in Orange County, CA
Explore More Topics
Ready to Get More Leads?
Get a free marketing audit for your contracting business. We'll show you exactly where you're losing leads.
Get Your Free AuditRelated Articles
Who AI Recommends: 123 Local Markets Compared
We compared the businesses ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews named across 123 trade-and-city markets. Only 1.6% of 2,578 businesses were named by all three engines.
What Do AI SEO Services Cost in 2026?
Five of 18 agencies we checked publish an AI SEO price. See every published rate, the terms behind it, what software costs, and where our own engines start.
Which Trades Do AI Engines Recommend Agencies For?
We tracked 13,113 ChatGPT and Perplexity answers across 310 BaaDigi-written prompts. For roofing, HVAC, painting and plumbing the most-cited source was Reddit, not an agency.