Comparisons
Contractor Lead Sources, Compared Honestly
Every lead platform and marketing agency contractors consider — broken down by real cost per lead, close rate, true cost per booked job, and whether you build an asset you own. No fluff, no affiliate spin. Just the math behind renting leads versus owning your pipeline.
HomeAdvisor vs Angi: Which Is Actually Better for Contractors in 2026?
HomeAdvisor vs Angi compared for 2026: real cost per lead ($15–$100+), shared-lead close rates (10–20%), and true cost per booked job ($250–$500). See which wins — and the exclusive-lead alternative that drops cost per booked job to $100–$200.
Read the comparisonCraftJack vs BaaDigi: Pay-Per-Lead vs Owning Your Pipeline
CraftJack vs owning your marketing: cost per lead, quality & long-term ROI. Why top contractors are switching.
Read the comparisonPorch Leads vs Building Your Own Lead Pipeline
Is Porch.com worth it for contractors? Compare Porch leads vs building your own exclusive pipeline. Real costs, close rates, and long-term ROI analysis.
Read the comparisonShared Leads vs Exclusive Leads: What Actually Costs Less Per Job?
Shared vs exclusive contractor leads: real cost per job, close rates & ROI. Why exclusive costs less per booked job.
Read the comparisonBaaDigi vs Scorpion: Which Contractor Marketing Agency Is Right for You?
BaaDigi vs Scorpion: pricing, services & results compared. Why contractors choose boutique over enterprise marketing.
Read the comparisonBaaDigi vs Contractor Marketing Pros: Two Contractor-Focused Agencies Compared
BaaDigi vs Contractor Marketing Pros: pricing, specialties, and results compared. Two contractor-focused agencies — see which fits your business better.
Read the comparisonBaaDigi vs Hook Agency: Which Contractor Marketing Agency Wins?
BaaDigi vs Hook Agency: contractor marketing agencies compared on pricing, services, and results. See which agency fits your home service business.
Read the comparisonThumbtack vs Building Your Own Contractor Lead Pipeline
Thumbtack vs building your own lead pipeline — real per-contact pricing, close rates, complaint patterns, and the math on cost per signed job.
Read the comparisonService Direct vs Building Your Own Contractor Lead Engine
Service Direct vs building your own lead pipeline — pay-per-call pricing, exclusive lead model, true cost per signed job, and the long-term play.
Read the comparisonNetworx vs Building Your Own Contractor Lead Engine
Networx vs building your own lead pipeline — pricing, shared lead model, complaint patterns, and the better long-term play for contractors.
Read the comparisonBark.com vs BaaDigi: Buying Credits vs Owning Your Pipeline
Bark.com sells credit-based leads (~$2.35/credit, ~6–12 credits per lead = roughly $15–$30 each) shared with up to 5 pros. See the real cost per booked job, the refund/expiry traps contractors hit, and the exclusive-lead alternative that drops cost per booked job to $100–$200 by month 12.
Read the comparisonModernize vs BaaDigi: Shared Home-Improvement Leads vs Owning Your Pipeline
Modernize sells shared home-improvement leads (solar from $100+, sold to multiple contractors) on a dynamic 'Right Pricing' model with no public rates. See real close-rate math vs the exclusive-lead alternative that drops cost per booked job to $100-$200 within 12 months.
Read the comparisonStart With the Data
Ready to Get More Leads?
Get a free marketing audit for your contracting business. We'll show you exactly where you're losing leads.
Get Your Free Audit