Back to BlogSEO Services

What Does a Local SEO Audit Actually Check?

Ryan Goering
7 min read
What Does a Local SEO Audit Actually Check?

A local SEO audit checks whether a business shows up where homeowners actually look, not just whether its website is healthy. That means seven things: name, address, and phone consistency across every listing; review count and recency; who else on the web mentions the business; whether the business owns its own name in search; active social profiles; whether AI assistants name the business; and how it stacks up against the three competitors in the map pack.

Last updated: October 2026. This is day four of a five-part series on auditing your own website with AI. Day three covered why service pages don't rank. Today the audit leaves your website entirely.

Free Agentic Browsing Audit

Can an AI agent actually use your website?

AI agents are starting to visit sites on a customer's behalf — comparing companies and requesting quotes. We run the same agentic browsing checks Google built into Chrome and show you what an agent hits when it lands on your site. No email to run it.

Why a website audit alone misses half the picture

Here is the uncomfortable part. A homeowner with a leaking roof does not go to your website first. They go to Google, look at the three businesses in the map, read the review counts, and call one. More and more of them ask ChatGPT or Perplexity instead and call whoever gets named. Your website might never enter it.

So the third pass of our audit prompt treats the website as one source among many. It fetches your contact page and footer, then spends most of its time searching the web for your business name, your trade plus your city, and your reviews, and asking itself the question a homeowner would ask. Here is what it checks and what we typically find.

Check 1: Name, address, and phone, everywhere, identical

Google builds its confidence in a business by cross-referencing the name, address, and phone number (NAP) across the website, Google Business Profile, Yelp, BBB, Facebook, Angi, Nextdoor, and trade directories. One old phone number on a directory you forgot about, a suite number on one listing and not another, "Smith Roofing" on one and "Smith Roofing Inc" on another, and the confidence drops.

The prompt reads your footer, then searches your business name and compares what every listing it finds says. It also checks that the LocalBusiness schema on your homepage matches the footer exactly. We wrote a full breakdown of what NAP consistency actually requires, and the short version is: the fix is boring, it takes an afternoon, and most of your competitors have not done it.

Check 2: Reviews, and whether anyone is answering them

The prompt reports the review count and average rating it can see in search results for Google and the other platforms. It is told to say plainly that these are numbers it saw in search, not live figures, because an AI model cannot log in to your Business Profile.

Fewer than 20 Google reviews, or an average under 4.5, is a warning for most trades. More important than the count is recency. Reviews that stopped eighteen months ago signal a business that stopped asking. The prompt also checks whether the owner responds, especially to negative reviews. Homeowners read the response more carefully than the complaint.

Check 3: Who else talks about you

Search your business name in quotes and read every result. That is what the prompt does, and it sorts what it finds into directories, local media, supplier and manufacturer pages, chamber of commerce, sponsorships, and social profiles.

Then it looks for two specific opportunities. First, pages that mention your business without linking to your site. Each one is a backlink you can ask for with a two-line email. Second, manufacturer "find a dealer" pages. If you install Owens Corning, Carrier, or Sherwin-Williams products and you are not listed on their dealer locator, that is a free link from a site Google trusts enormously. Most contractors are certified and never listed.

Check 4: Do you own your own name?

Search your exact business name. Your website should be the first result, with sitelinks underneath. If a directory outranks you for your own name, or worse, a competitor's ad sits on top, you have a brand problem that costs you calls every day.

The prompt also checks for a Knowledge Panel and tells you where to look in Search Console for the number that matters most here: how many clicks per month come from searches that include your business name. In our experience that number rising is the earliest signal of revenue growth there is. It tends to show up sixty to ninety days before the phone does.

Is your own website costing you leads?

Free scan — speed, mobile, local visibility, and lead capture. Results in about 30 seconds.

Check 5: Social and physical presence

Active profiles on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, LinkedIn, and Nextdoor. Active means a post in the last sixty days. Same logo, same name, same phone on all of them. And somewhere online, a photo of the actual office, the actual trucks, the actual crew. Google uses these as signals that the business is real and operating. So do homeowners.

Check 6: Does AI know you exist?

This is the check that did not exist three years ago and now matters as much as the map pack. The prompt does four things:

  • Checks for an llms.txt file on your site, a plain-text summary of what you do and where. Cheap to add, and a growing number of AI crawlers read it first.
  • Confirms AI crawlers are not blocked in robots.txt (pass one covered this, but it is worth confirming).
  • Reads your service pages to see whether each one opens with a direct answer to "what is this and who is it for" before the marketing copy. AI systems quote those opening sentences. If your page opens with "Welcome to Smith Roofing, where quality meets integrity," there is nothing to quote.
  • Asks itself the question a homeowner would ask: "Who is a good roofer in Costa Mesa?" Then it reports whether your business came up, and which sources it would have cited. That source list is your roadmap. If it would have cited Yelp and a local news story, those are the places you need to be stronger.

We have written about why ChatGPT recommends the local businesses it does and how to check whether it recommends yours. The pattern is consistent: AI assistants name businesses that are described clearly, mentioned often, and reviewed recently. The same things Google rewards, with less tolerance for vagueness.

Check 7: The three businesses beating you

The prompt searches your trade plus your city and names the three businesses in the map pack or top organic results. For each it notes the review count, the rating, and whether their site has a dedicated page for your city. Then it states the single biggest gap between you and the top one.

That one sentence is usually the whole audit. It tends to read something like: "The top competitor has several times your review count and a page for every city you serve." Everything else is detail.

What the prompt returns

Pass three returns a scorecard for the seven checks with the evidence URL or search for each; two lists, where the business was found and where it was missing while competitors were present; a fix list ordered by impact, written so an office manager can do most of it without a developer (claim the listing, fix the phone number, ask the supplier for the link, text the last ten customers for a review); and the items that need Google Business Profile or Search Console access, with the exact report named.

Run it yourself

Pass three is a single prompt file. It needs four things filled in: site URL, trade, business name, and primary city. Paste it into Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini with browsing on.

Get it here: Pass 3: Visibility on GitHub.

Tomorrow, day five: we ran passes one and two against ten real roofing websites in Orange County. The results surprised us.

If you would rather we ran it

Everything in pass three is what our AI visibility audit measures with real tools instead of a model's best effort: citation tracking across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews, a full listing sweep, and a review velocity read. It feeds directly into the local work inside our contractor SEO service. If you want to know where you stand against the three businesses above you in the map, request a free audit.

Free website audit — see what's costing you leads

No email required. Takes 2 minutes. Completely free.

local seo auditlocal seoai search visibilityai audit prompt
Ryan Goering

Ryan Goering

CEO & Founder, BaaDigi

U.S. military veteran and digital marketing strategist who built BaaDigi to help contractors generate predictable leads and revenue. 15+ years in SEO, PPC, and AI-powered marketing automation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a local SEO audit and a regular SEO audit?▼

A regular SEO audit looks at your website: whether Google can crawl it, whether the pages are well built, whether the content is deep enough. A local SEO audit looks at everything around your website: your Google Business Profile, your listings on Yelp and the trade directories, your reviews, who mentions and links to you, whether you own your own name in search, and now, whether AI assistants name you. For a contractor, the local audit usually explains more of the lost calls than the website audit does.

How many Google reviews does a contractor need?▼

Enough to be competitive in your own map pack, which is a local number, not a national one. The prompt flags fewer than 20 reviews or an average under 4.5 as a warning for most trades, but the real benchmark is the three businesses above you. If they have 200 and you have 40, the count is your problem. If everyone has 40, recency and responses are. Reviews that stopped eighteen months ago signal a business that stopped asking.

Can ChatGPT really recommend a local contractor?▼

Yes, and it does every day. Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Google's AI Mode for a good roofer in your city and it will name two to five businesses and cite sources: Google reviews, Yelp, local news, and the businesses' own websites. The pattern is consistent. AI assistants name businesses that are described clearly on their own site, mentioned often on other sites, and reviewed recently. The prompt asks that exact question and reports whether you came up and which sources it would have cited.

What is an llms.txt file and does a contractor need one?▼

It is a plain-text file at yoursite.com/llms.txt that summarizes what your business does, where it operates, and which pages matter most, written for AI crawlers the way robots.txt is written for search crawlers. It is an emerging standard, not a requirement, and its absence is a warning rather than a failure. It takes ten minutes to add, costs nothing, and a growing number of AI systems read it first, so there is no reason not to.

What should I fix first after a local SEO audit?▼

In this order: any mismatch in your name, address, or phone across listings, because it undermines everything else; then claim or correct any listing where competitors appear and you do not, especially manufacturer dealer locators; then ask your last ten customers for a Google review and respond to every review you already have; then add llms.txt and a direct opening sentence to each service page. Most of that is an afternoon of office work, not a developer project.

Ready to Get More Leads?

Get a free marketing audit for your contracting business. We'll show you exactly where you're losing leads.

Get Your Free Audit