Back to BlogSEO Services

SEO for Contractors: Why Don't Your Service Pages Rank?

Ryan Goering
8 min read
SEO for Contractors: Why Don't Your Service Pages Rank?

Contractor service pages fail to rank for three reasons, in order of how often we see them: the page is under 300 words of generic copy, the title and H1 don't name the service and the city, and the site has multiple pages competing for the same keyword. SEO for contractors is mostly fixing those three things on the pages that already exist, before writing anything new.

Last updated: October 2026. This is day three of a five-part series on auditing your own website with AI. Day two covered the six foundation checks that come before any of this.

Free Agentic Browsing Audit

Can an AI agent actually use your website?

AI agents are starting to visit sites on a customer's behalf — comparing companies and requesting quotes. We run the same agentic browsing checks Google built into Chrome and show you what an agent hits when it lands on your site. No email to run it.

What "SEO for contractors" actually means on the page

Strip away the agency language and SEO for a contractor comes down to one question: when a homeowner in your city searches for the thing you do, does Google have a reason to show your page instead of the other forty? That reason has to live on the page. Not in your reputation, not in your truck wrap, on the page.

The second pass of our audit prompt reads every service page on your site and checks eight things. Here they are, with the pattern we see on real contractor sites for each.

Titles and descriptions: the first thing Google reads, the last thing anyone writes

A title tag is the blue link in search results. For a service page it should be 50 to 60 characters and name the service and the area near the front: "Roof Repair in Huntington Beach | Smith Roofing." We routinely find three patterns instead:

  • The title is just the company name. Every page on the site has the same title.
  • The title is 90 characters and gets cut off mid-sentence in results.
  • The title is "Services" or "Home."

The meta description is the gray text under the link. It does not affect ranking directly, but it decides whether anyone clicks. It should include the service and one reason to pick you: licensed, same-day, financing, twenty years in the area. The prompt flags missing, duplicated, and obviously auto-generated descriptions, and it writes the replacement title and description for you in the fix list.

Headings: one H1, and it says what the page is about

Every page needs exactly one H1, and it should name the service. "Welcome" is not a service. The company name is not a service. We find pages with zero H1s because the theme used an H1 for the logo and the developer removed it, and pages with six H1s because the page builder makes every section heading an H1 by default.

Under the H1, the H2s should mark the real sections of the page. The prompt pulls the full heading outline for each page so you can see at a glance whether it reads like a table of contents or like noise.

Service page depth: the check most contractor sites fail

This is the big one. We will say it plainly: a 180-word service page with stock photos does not rank in 2026, no matter what else you do. Google has forty other pages for the same search and most of them say more.

The prompt counts words on every service page. Under 300 is thin. Under 600 is weak for a primary service. But word count is a symptom. The real test is whether the page answers what a homeowner actually wants to know before they call:

  • What is included in the job?
  • How long does it take?
  • What affects the price?
  • What areas do you cover?
  • What makes you different from the other guy?
  • What happens after I call?

Then it asks a harder question: is there anything on this page that only this company could have written? A real photo from a real job. A named crew lead. A specific detail about the local building code, the local weather, the local HOA rules. Generic copy that could be swapped onto a competitor's site without editing is a flag, and it is what most contractor sites are made of. We cover this from the plumbing side in what plumber SEO should focus on, and the pattern is identical in every trade.

Finally, the prompt checks that the page has a clear next step above the fold (phone, form, or booking link) and again at the bottom. A service page that ranks and does not convert is just expensive wallpaper.

Is your own website costing you leads?

Free scan — speed, mobile, local visibility, and lead capture. Results in about 30 seconds.

Duplicate and templated pages: the problem that hides in plain sight

Two versions of this. The first is city pages. A lot of contractor sites have a page for every city in the service area, and every one of them is the same 400 words with the city name swapped. Google collapses these into one and often ranks none of them. The prompt compares city pages against each other and flags the ones that are near-identical.

The second is cannibalization: two pages on your own site targeting the same service, something like /roof-repair and /roofing-repair-services. Each one weakens the other. The prompt finds the pairs and recommends which one to keep. On a site that has been around a decade and had three different people adding pages, this check alone can be worth more than everything else combined.

Internal links: the thing nobody does on purpose

Internal links are how Google learns which pages on your site matter and how they relate. Contractor sites tend to have links only in the navigation and footer, and none in the body copy. That means every page looks equally unimportant.

The prompt checks that every service page is linked from the homepage body (not only the menu), that each service page links to at least two related pages in its text using descriptive anchor text, that city pages and service pages link to each other, and that no page is an orphan with zero inbound links. It also catches the technical versions of the problem: links that point to a redirecting URL, and links with rel="nofollow" that a plugin added to every internal link on the site.

The anchor text rule matters more than it sounds. "Click here" tells Google nothing. "Roof leak repair in Costa Mesa" tells Google exactly what the destination page is about.

Images: real job photos, named properly

Three checks. Every image has alt text that describes it. File names describe the content instead of IMG_4823.jpg. And the photos are real jobs, not stock. The prompt notes the ratio it sees. A roofing site with twelve stock photos and zero real roofs is telling Google, and every homeowner who lands there, that it has nothing to show.

Structured data: tell Google what kind of business this is

Structured data is a block of code on the page that tells search engines and AI systems exactly what they are looking at. For a contractor, the homepage should carry LocalBusiness schema (or the specific subtype: RoofingContractor, HVACBusiness, Plumber) with name, phone, address, service area, hours, and links to the Google Business Profile and social pages. Service pages should carry Service schema. Blog posts should carry Article with a real author and real dates.

The prompt reads the schema on every page and flags two things: schema that is missing, and schema that lies. Reviews in the schema that are not visible on the page. An address in the schema that differs from the footer. Google has gotten strict about the second kind, and it feeds directly into the NAP consistency problems we see on most local sites.

Trust and authorship: is there a person here?

The last check is simple. Is there a real human on the site? An owner's name and photo. A license number where a homeowner would look for it. Years in business. Dates on blog posts. "About Us" pages with no names and no faces fail this check, and they fail it with homeowners before they fail it with Google.

What the prompt returns

Pass two returns a page table (URL, title length, meta length, H1, word count, schema found, issues) for every page it fetched, a scorecard for the eight checks with the worst offender named for each, a numbered fix list that includes the actual replacement titles and the list of questions each thin page needs to answer, and the one thing it cannot see: which pages are sitting in positions 4 to 15 in Search Console. Those are the pages to fix first, because they are closest to page one.

Run it yourself

Pass two is a single prompt file. Copy it, replace the site URL and trade, paste it into Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini with browsing on.

Get it here: Pass 2: Pages on GitHub.

Tomorrow, day four: the pass that leaves your website entirely and checks where homeowners actually find you, from the map pack to ChatGPT.

If you would rather we ran it

Thin service pages are among the first things we fix with a new client, and rewriting them is the core of our SEO for contractors work. If your site has been live for years and nobody has looked at it page by page, request a free audit. We will send back the page table and tell you which three pages to fix first.

Free website audit — see what's costing you leads

No email required. Takes 2 minutes. Completely free.

seo for contractorsservice pageson-page seoai audit prompt
Ryan Goering

Ryan Goering

CEO & Founder, BaaDigi

U.S. military veteran and digital marketing strategist who built BaaDigi to help contractors generate predictable leads and revenue. 15+ years in SEO, PPC, and AI-powered marketing automation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many words should a contractor service page have?▼

There is no magic number, but under 300 words will not compete in 2026 and under 600 is weak for a primary service like roof replacement or AC installation. Word count is a symptom, though. The real test is whether the page answers what a homeowner wants to know before calling: what is included, how long it takes, what affects price, what areas you cover, what makes you different, and what happens after they call. A page that answers those honestly usually lands between 800 and 1,500 words on its own.

What is keyword cannibalization and why does it matter for contractors?▼

Cannibalization is two or more pages on your own site targeting the same search, for example /roof-repair and /roofing-repair-services. Google has to pick one, often picks neither consistently, and each page weakens the other. It is common on contractor sites that have been live for years with several people adding pages. The fix is to keep the stronger page, redirect the weaker one to it, and fold any unique content across. The prompt finds the pairs and recommends which to keep.

Do city pages still work for contractor SEO?▼

Yes, if each one is genuinely different. A page for every city in your service area works when it carries real local detail: jobs you have done there, neighborhood names, local permit or HOA quirks, photos from that city. It fails when it is the same 400 words with the city name swapped. Google collapses templated city pages and often ranks none of them. The prompt compares your city pages against each other and flags near-duplicates.

What schema markup does a contractor website need?▼

At minimum: LocalBusiness schema on the homepage (or the specific subtype such as RoofingContractor, HVACBusiness, or Plumber) with name, phone, address, service area, hours, and sameAs links to your Google Business Profile and social pages; Service schema on each service page; Article schema with a real author and dates on blog posts; and BreadcrumbList on every page. Just as important, the schema must match what is visible on the page. Schema that claims reviews or an address the page does not show gets you in trouble.

Which service pages should I fix first?▼

The ones already ranking in positions 4 to 15 in Google Search Console. Those pages are getting impressions but few clicks, and they are the closest to page one. The AI prompt cannot see Search Console, so it tells you to pull that list yourself. Cross it against the prompt's page table: a page in position 8 with a 25-character title and 200 words is your first fix.

Ready to Get More Leads?

Get a free marketing audit for your contracting business. We'll show you exactly where you're losing leads.

Get Your Free Audit